Skip to content


My Husband had a Baby with My Lesbian Sister

Why did I go along with it? I guess I feel like everyone has the right to experience motherhood and parenting. And the thought of my sister picking sperm from a catalog just made me sad. I don’t know, maybe it was all the wine I’d drunk that night. But when Marnie asked us, it seemed like the most natural idea in the world. Of course, I assumed they would use a more clinical method. I also assumed Marnie was pretty set on the whole women-loving-women thing. Now they live in Palm Springs, Marnie and Bill and baby make three.

***
Title by: K. Hart
Story by: Jenny

2 people like this story.

Related posts:

  1. The Surprising Fall of Ms. Hart
  2. A bleak afterthought (Jenny Version)
  3. A Stray Cat Named Bill Cosby
  4. I Don’t Know Why You Like to Make Baby Jesus Cry
  5. Why am I alone

Posted in Stories.

Tagged with .


5 Responses

Stay in touch with the conversation, subscribe to the RSS feed for comments on this post.

  1. Jarvis Slacks says

    Amazing. Simply amazing.

  2. jenny says

    Thanks Jarvis!

  3. K. Hart says

    This is great, jenny! Thanks!

    If only things had gone so, um, well. Turns out he handed over the sperm sample without my prior knowledge and after the baby was born my sister’s girlfriend (now wife) tried to steal my husband. Needless to say, hubby and I split up, I had an affair with my first baby daddy, and my niece/stepdaughter has been banished from my sight to another continent.

    [WORDPRESS HASHCASH] The poster sent us ‘0 which is not a hashcash value.

  4. Colin Dodd says

    These are getting really good.

    You must have enough for a cloth-bound, limited edition McSweeny’s collection by now.

  5. jenny says

    We definitely have a lot of stories. Thanks for the compliment, Colin. We’ve been thinking about doing a printed version of some kind…



Some HTML is OK

or, reply to this post via trackback.



Creative Commons License